Why Was Esdras Taken Out Of The Bible

Background Information

Esdras is a book in the Bible which is not found in most Protestant religions, including the popular King James Version. The book contains prophecies of the prophet Esdras, who lived during the sixth century BC. Additionally, Esdras contains words of advice, which could be viewed as a foreshadowing of Jesus’ time on earth.

Since Esdras was written before Jesus’ life, some Biblical scholars believe it should be considered canonical. The book also appears in the Septuagint, which is the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible. Therefore, it is seen as an important part of the Old Testament.

However, due to the fact that it was written prior to Jesus’ time, many people argue that it should not be seen as canonical. Additionally, there are several Christian denominations who don’t accept the book as authoritative, such as the Church of England. These denominations believe that Esdras should be acknowledged as historical writing, but not as part of the Bible.

Relevant Data

Although the debate about the status of Esdras continues, it is a fact that it does not appear in the King James Version of the Bible. This version of the Bible was published in 1611 and is based on the work of William Tyndale, who also excluded the book from his gospel. Thus, the Church of England and most other Protestant denominations have followed this decision.

Furthermore, the Catholic Church also does not include Esdras in its canon. While the book remains in the Catholic Bible, it is placed at the end, before the Prayer of Manasseh. Additionally, the chapters of Esdras are not numbered, which is a clear indicator of its lower status.

The Council of Hippo in AD 393 was the first to set out the canon of the Bible, but the church did not include Esdras. The Alexandrian Council of AD 367 also did not include Esdras in its version of the Bible. In spite of this, some individuals argue that the book should be added to the Bible, due to its importance for the history of Christianity.

Expert Perspectives

Some scholars argue that Esdras should be included in the Bible, as it is part of the collection of early Jewish writings known as the Apocrypha. According to the British scholar Edward Miller, “Though the book of Esdras is not canonical, it is interesting and important for early Christian history.”

Another expert on Biblical studies, Ben Witherington, believes that although Esdras is not accepted as part of the canon, it is still a valuable document. He states, “Esdras is a very old document, and it is certainly important for Bible study. It contains some prophecies and words of advice that are essential for the interpretation of the New Testament.”

Professor of Religion at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary Michael S. Heiser adds, “Esdras is a good example of how religious texts have evolved over time and how our understanding of Christianity has changed. Even though it is not part of the canon, we cannot overlook its significance in terms of understanding the broader context of the Bible.”


The debate around the book of Esdras highlights the difficulty in determining the canon of the Bible. It also shows how views on which books should be included in the Bible have changed over time. For example, we can see from William Tyndale’s work that even during the Reformation period, different scholars had different views on the accepted books.

Thus, Esdras provides an interesting example of how our views on the Bible have evolved and developed over centuries. In spite of its controversial status, Esdras is a valuable document which provides insight into both the history of Christianity and early Jewish writings.

Is Esdras Relevant Today?

Even though Esdras is not part of the accepted Bible, it can still be seen as an important document in terms of understanding the early days of Christianity. Many of its teachings and prophecies are still relevant today and have influenced Christian thought and morality. Additionally, it can also be seen as an example of how our views on the Bible have evolved over time.

However, whether the book of Esdras should be seen ascanonical is still a matter of debate. While there are some who argue for its inclusion, the majority of Christian denominations do not accept it as part of the Bible. Thus, it is likely that Esdras will remain a controversial topic for years to come.

The Influence of Esdras

Esdras has had a significant impact on Christian teaching, culture, and literature. For example, its prophecies were used by writers of the New Testament, such as Paul and the writers of Revelation. Additionally, the book has provided inspiration for Christian writers, such as Dante and Milton.

The book also contains many teachings which are still relevant today. These include themes such as the importance of justice, mercy, and humility. Esdras also encourages faithfulness and warns against false prophets, both of which are important for Christian life today.

In spite of the fact that Esdras is not accepted as part of the Bible, its teachings still remain important for many people today. Therefore, it is clear that the book of Esdras should not be forgotten but should be seen as an important part of the history of Christianity.

Esdras’ Significance Today

Although Esdras is not included in the accepted Bible, its teachings and prophecies remain important for Christians today. Its emphasis on justice, mercy, and humility can help to shape the moral and ethical decisions that people make today. Additionally, its warnings against false prophets have great relevance in the modern world, where disinformation and fake news are so prevalent.

Furthermore, the book also serves as a reminder of how our views on the Bible have changed over time. It marks an important step in the evolution of Christianity, as it shows how faith can be interpreted in different ways. Therefore, Esdras can help Christians today to think more deeply about the place and importance of the Bible in today’s society.

Ultimately, the book of Esdras highlights the importance of looking to the past in order to understand the present. Despite its controversial status, it can still provide a valuable source of knowledge for Christians today.

Hilda Scott is an avid explorer of the Bible and inteprator of its gospel. She is passionate about researching and uncovering the mysteries that lie in this sacred book. She hopes to use her knowledge and expertise to bring faith and God closer to people all around the world.

Leave a Comment